Why did John McCaffary's execution abolish the death penalty?
John McCaffary was an Irish-American farmer convicted of murdering his wife in Kenosha, Wisconsin. His August 1851 execution by hanging was severely botched, leaving him to strangle slowly for over twenty minutes. This public spectacle and prolonged agony outraged the public and directly led Wisconsin to abolish capital punishment in 1853, becoming a pioneer among U.S. states.
What we know
- John McCaffary was convicted and executed for the murder of his wife, Bridgett McCaffary. [2, 3]
- McCaffary was hanged on August 21, 1851, in Kenosha County after drowning his wife in a backyard cistern. [2, 5]
- The hanging was botched, causing McCaffary to be unintentionally strangled for over 20 minutes before he died. [2, 5]
- McCaffary is the first and only person ever executed by the State of Wisconsin. [3, 5]
- Wisconsin abolished capital punishment just two years after McCaffary's execution, in 1853. [2, 3, 5]
Where to go next
- what followedHow did Wisconsin abolish capital punishment?
- how it workedWhat happens during a botched hanging?
- whereWhere did the murder take place?
- whoWho was Bridgett McCaffary?
- the bigger pictureWhat other methods result in botched executions?
- an unexpected connectionHow does a historic murder site become a protected landmark?The house where John McCaffary murdered his wife was added to the National Register of Historic Places in 1978.
Sources
- [1]John McCaffary (Wikidata Q6247416) · CC0 1.0
- [2]John McCaffary · CC BY-SA 4.0
- [3]John McCaffary House · CC BY-SA 4.0
- [4]List of botched executions · CC BY-SA 4.0
- [5]Capital punishment in Wisconsin · CC BY-SA 4.0